Why Is College So Expensive? The Real Story Behind Rising Education Costs

If you've looked at college tuition bills lately, you've probably done a double-take. Maybe even a triple-take. The numbers are jaw-dropping, and if you're wondering whether you're missing something or if college really has gotten that expensive—well, you're not imagining things. It really has.

Let's dive into what's actually happening with higher education costs in America, why your parents' college experience was so much more affordable than yours (or your kids'), and why some surprising players are stepping up to help solve this problem.

A piggy bank representing savings for education.

First, Let's Talk Numbers (Don't Worry, We'll Keep It Painless)

According to the College Board, here's what college costs look like for the 2025-2026 academic year:

• Public four-year colleges: $11,950 for in-state students, $31,880 if you're coming from out of state

• Private four-year colleges: Around $45,000

• And that's just tuition and fees—add room, board, textbooks, and that questionable meal plan, and you're easily looking at $50,000+ per year at many schools

Now here's the kicker: Between 2001 and 2021, college tuition jumped 62% at public schools and 32% at private schools—and that's after adjusting for inflation, according to BestColleges. To put that in perspective, while everything else got about 39% more expensive, college tuition shot up 68%.

And if you really want your mind blown, Education Data Initiative reports that since 1963, college costs have increased by over 312% when you account for inflation. That's not a typo.

The result? Americans now collectively owe about $1.81 trillion in student loans, affecting more than 42.5 million people. The average borrower carries around $39,075 in federal student loan debt. That's like buying a pretty nice car, except you can't drive it anywhere.

So... What Happened?

Great question. It's not just one thing—it's more like a perfect storm of factors that all hit at once. Let's break them down.

Your Professor Still Can't Be Replaced by a Robot (The Baumol Effect)

There's this economic concept called the Baumol Effect, and it helps explain a lot. Basically, some industries can get more efficient over time—factories can automate, software can scale—but education? It still requires actual human beings teaching actual human beings.

According to SSTI research, faculty salaries and benefits make up about 34% of what it costs to run a four-year public university. As wages rise across the entire economy, colleges have to compete for talented professors, but they can't make teaching dramatically more "efficient" without sacrificing quality. A professor teaching 20 students can't suddenly teach 200 without something getting lost.

The below chart provides an illustrative, quantified example of the Baumol Effect, using 1970 as the base year, and assuming a productivity gap of 3% between manufacturing and education.  Even though productivity improves little in education, wages must rise to compete with other sectors where productivity is increasing rapidly. This causes education costs to rise faster than manufacturing costs over time.

States Started Backing Away

Here's the big one: State governments used to foot a much larger portion of the bill for public colleges and universities. Then 2008 happened, budgets got tight, and many states decided higher education funding was a place they could cut.

The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities found that 32 states were spending less per student in 2020 than they did in 2008—an average drop of nearly $1,500 per student. The American Academy of Arts and Sciences notes that 46 states cut support between 2008 and 2014, with many slashing over 20% of their funding.

When states stop paying, guess who picks up the tab? Yep, students and their families. As the National Education Association points out, when state funding goes down, tuition goes up. It's almost a one-to-one relationship.

There Are a Lot More Administrators Now

This one gets people fired up. Between 1976 and 2018, the number of administrative positions at colleges grew by 164%, while student enrollment only grew 92%.

The American Council of Trustees and Alumni found that spending on administration per student jumped 61% between 1993 and 2007. The Goldwater Institute reports that by 2007, there were 39% more administrators per 100 students compared to 1993, while the number of professors per 100 students only increased by 18%.

To be fair, some of this growth handles real needs—think compliance officers, IT staff, mental health counselors, disability services. But critics argue that universities have become bloated bureaucracies where it sometimes feels like there are more people managing things than actually teaching.

Campus Life Got Really, Really Nice

Remember when dorms were just places to sleep? Now they're luxury apartments with private bathrooms, full kitchens, and maybe even a lazy river (yes, really). According to Bankrate, colleges are competing on amenities—state-of-the-art gyms, gourmet dining options, fancy student centers.

Students expect this stuff now, and it helps schools attract applicants. But building and maintaining these facilities costs serious money, and those costs get passed along in tuition and fees.

Then there's technology. Every classroom needs the latest smart boards, every student needs access to sophisticated software, and the whole campus needs bulletproof cybersecurity and lightning-fast Wi-Fi. None of this is cheap.

The Financial Aid Catch-22

Here's an ironic twist: Financial aid might actually be making things worse. It's called the Bennett Hypothesis (named after a former Education Secretary), and the idea is pretty straightforward—when the government makes more loans and grants available, colleges know students can borrow more, so they feel free to raise prices.

As Bankrate explains, it's a bit like health insurance and medical costs: When someone else is paying (or at least fronting the money), prices tend to go up. The research on this is mixed, but there's definitely some truth to it.

A Surprising Solution: Your Employer Might Help

Here's where things get interesting. While we're all wringing our hands about college costs, some companies have been quietly stepping up with a solution: employer-sponsored 529 savings plans.

You might have heard of 529 plans—they're tax-advantaged savings accounts specifically designed for education expenses. But here's what's new: a growing number of employers are now offering these plans as a workplace benefit, either through payroll deduction options or, even better, by contributing directly to employees' accounts.

The Numbers That Show Employees Really Want This

The demand is real. According to research from Ascensus, while only 7% of employers currently offer a 529 plan, a whopping 49% of workers say they're interested in having one as a benefit. That's actually higher than the interest in student loan repayment programs (47%), which get way more media attention.

A Commonwealth report found that employees were especially interested in workplace 529 plans, particularly those from low- and moderate-income households. Another study showed that 96% of low- to middle-income parents expressed interest in opening a 529 plan if their employer offered it. Even more telling: 93% of Colorado families said they wish their employer would help with education savings.

And people are clearly concerned about this issue. A Guardian study found that the percentage of workers rating saving for their children's education as "highly important" jumped 16% just between 2016 and 2018. According to Gusto's 2022 survey, 55% of Americans still see saving for higher education as critically important, even with all the economic uncertainty we've faced.

Why Companies Are Jumping on Board

For employers, offering 529 plans is surprisingly easy and increasingly incentivized. Most programs require minimal administrative effort—employees simply set up their accounts and arrange payroll deductions. Many state 529 programs even provide free educational resources, lunch-and-learn sessions, and materials that companies can share with employees.

But here's where it gets really interesting: Nine states now offer tax credits or deductions to employers who match employee contributions to 529 plans, and several have recently sweetened their incentives to make them even more attractive.

According to Saving for College and The New York Times, here's what employers can get:

• Arkansas: State income tax deduction for 529 contributions; maximum $500 per employee per year

• Colorado: 20% tax credit on contributions; maximum $500 credit per employee per year (meaning employers can contribute $2,500 and receive $500 back)

• Idaho: Tax credit for employer matching contributions

• Illinois: 25% tax credit; maximum $500 per employee per year; unused credits can be carried forward for five years

• Nebraska: 25% tax credit; maximum $2,000 credit per employee per year

• Nevada: 25% tax credit; maximum $800 per employee per year

• Pennsylvania: 25% tax credit effective January 2025; maximum $500 per employee per year (so a $500 contribution yields a $125 credit)

• Utah: State income tax deduction; maximum $1,960 per year

• Wisconsin: 50% tax credit; maximum $800 per employee per year (revised upward from $240 in recent years)

In many states, these credits can be carried forward for multiple years if they exceed the employer's tax liability, making them even more valuable. And the College Savings Plans Network notes that at least eight states have these programs, with more considering similar legislation.

For employees, the benefits are clear. Sallie Mae found that parents who use 529 plans save 76% more for college than parents who saved without one. The College Savings Plans Network reports that families had more than $508 billion tucked away in 529 accounts as of June 2024—nearly double what was saved a decade ago.

Companies like PCL Construction in Denver and Michigan-based Dawn Food Products have been offering payroll deduction 529 plans for years, with employees contributing anywhere from $15 per paycheck to much more. As one industry expert noted, offering a 529 plan signals that your organization is invested in employees' long-term goals, not just their day-to-day productivity. It builds goodwill, strengthens your employer brand, and helps retain talent—especially among younger workers planning for families.

The Bottom Line

Look, employer-sponsored 529 plans aren't going to fix everything that's broken about college financing in America. We still need to address the underlying issues—state disinvestment, administrative bloat, and the complicated relationship between financial aid and tuition.

But in the meantime? If you're job hunting or evaluating your current benefits package, it's worth asking whether your employer offers a 529 plan with payroll deduction or matching contributions. With nearly half of all workers interested in this benefit but only 7% of employers currently offering it, there's a huge gap between what employees want and what companies are providing.

More and more companies are recognizing that helping employees save for their families' education isn't just good for workers—it's good for business too. Whether it's a simple payroll deduction option or generous matching contributions that come with tax credits for the company, these programs make a real difference for families trying to navigate the increasingly expensive world of higher education.

College might be expensive, but at least some employers are stepping up to help families plan ahead. And in an economy where the average American is struggling under the weight of education costs, that partnership between employers and families might just be one of the smartest workplace innovations we've seen in a while.

After all, if we can't make college cheaper overnight, at least we can make it easier for families to save for it—one paycheck at a time.

///

Questions or comments on this content?  Email us at info@gohadley.com; we’re always open to feedback, ideas, or suggestions.